A Pellucid guide

How to Evaluate Accounts Receivable Software: A Buyer’s Guide

How finance leaders can compare AR platforms using their own invoices, systems and controls.

Choosing accounts receivable software means deciding which work a product can take on reliably and what your team will still need to do. A convincing demonstration can show a reminder being drafted or a payment being matched. The harder questions concern what happens when a customer disputes the invoice, a payment arrives without a clear reference, or important information sits in another system.

Those are the situations that determine whether software reduces work or creates another queue for people to manage.

AR vendors describe their products as AI-powered, AI-driven or AI-native. These labels can be a starting point for questions, but the evidence comes from how the product handles your records, follows your policies and responds when it cannot complete a task.

This guide is for B2B finance teams evaluating AR software, particularly those managing growing invoice volumes, recurring exceptions or information spread across several systems. It explains what to assess, how to test it and how to compare the results before making a commitment.

1. Start with where your cash gets stuck

Before booking demonstrations, document the work you want to improve. “Reduce DSO” is a useful business objective, but it does not tell a vendor whether your main problem is missing purchase orders, slow dispute resolution, incomplete remittances or follow-up that happens too late.

Start by tracing a sample of recent invoices through the process. Include routine cases as well as delayed or disputed ones. Record what held up progress, where someone looked for information, which colleagues became involved and what finally resolved the case. Our guide to why B2B invoices remain unpaid explores this investigation in more detail.

Build a short operating brief with four parts:

  • Volume and payment mix: invoices, active customers and receipts per month; payment methods; and the frequency of combined, partial and short payments.
  • Systems and records: accounting and billing systems, shared inboxes, bank accounts, payment processors, customer AP portals and any CRM information finance relies on.
  • People and authority: who performs each task, what is outsourced, who resolves exceptions and who approves credits, payment plans or write-offs.
  • Cost of the problem: investigation time, delayed receipts, rework, customer complaints and the effort required from other teams.

Then select the two or three problems that matter most. For example, a team spending hours matching receipts from parent companies needs evidence of payer identification and allocation. A team struggling with rejected invoices needs evidence of document handling, portal visibility and ownership of corrections. These lead to different evaluations.

Establish a baseline you can use later

Choose measures that reflect the problems you identified. Use consistent definitions, reporting periods and account populations so a change in calculation does not look like an improvement in performance.

MeasureWhat it helps assess
Days sales outstanding (DSO)Aggregate receivables relative to credit sales, expressed in days.
Best possible DSOCurrent, non-past-due receivables relative to credit sales, expressed in days.
Average days delinquent (ADD)DSO minus best possible DSO.
Collection effectiveness index (CEI)Collection effectiveness for a defined period.
Receivables over 90 days past dueOlder delinquent balances, reported as an amount and share of receivables.
Unapplied cashReceipts awaiting allocation, including their age and investigation effort.
Disputes and deductionsAmounts affected, resolution time and recurring causes.
Team effort and errorsReview hours, rework, incorrect actions and reversals.

The Credit Research Foundation’s Performance Measures guide defines DSO, best possible DSO, ADD and CEI and discusses their limitations. For a single month:

CEI = [(opening receivables + credit sales during the month − closing total receivables) ÷ (opening receivables + credit sales during the month − closing current receivables)] × 100

Here, “current” means not past due. Agree on treatment of credits, write-offs and other adjustments before comparing results.

Pair financial measures with operational ones. Sales patterns and payment terms can change DSO, while faster allocation of money already received does not establish that customers paid sooner. Measure the work the product is meant to improve directly.

2. Understand the approaches you may encounter

AR software can combine several delivery models and technologies. It helps to distinguish where the capability lives, how it makes decisions and who operates it.

Where the capability lives

Your accounting system may already provide some of the invoicing, reminder, payment-recording or cash-application functions you need. Begin by checking the features available in your edition and any additional modules. That establishes a practical baseline for the cost and effort of adding another platform.

A dedicated AR platform connects to the accounting system and provides additional workflows. Its value depends on which gaps it closes and how well those workflows connect back to the records your finance team maintains. Ask whether a demonstrated function is included, requires another module or depends on a separate service.

How decisions are made

Rules can enforce explicit policies, such as when an approved reminder should be sent or which checks a payment must pass before allocation. Machine learning can support predictions, prioritization and matching. Language models and agents can interpret communications, assemble context and prepare or execute permitted steps.

These approaches can work together. A model might interpret a remittance document while software checks the extracted values and enforces an approval limit. Ask the vendor to explain that division of responsibility for a real case, including what happens when the checks fail.

Who operates the process

With software alone, your team remains responsible for running the process and resolving the work the product cannot complete. A managed service adds an external team that may investigate exceptions, perform collections or maintain configurations.

Clarify which work is performed by the product, the provider’s staff and your own team. That distinction affects cost, response time, accountability and what happens when volume grows. Establish who may communicate with customers and which commercial decisions remain with your organization.

3. Evaluate what AI contributes to the work

A useful AI evaluation follows an invoice from incoming information to an action and its outcome. It should reveal what the product understands, what evidence it uses and how much work remains for a person.

Connections and access to information

Ask which records the AI can actually use in the release you would buy. A product that reads ledger balances but cannot access remittances or customer replies will have a different view from one that can connect those records.

Request a demonstration using a case where the relevant information is split across sources. Identify which connections are live, which information was uploaded for the demo and which steps require manual preparation. This makes the data requirements behind the result visible.

Consistent identification of customers and records

The same customer may appear under a trading name in the ledger, a legal name in bank data and a parent company’s name on a remittance. The product needs a way to connect these identities without merging unrelated accounts.

Test how it distinguishes payer, customer and legal entity, especially when invoice numbers or amounts repeat. Ask who reviews uncertain relationships and how a corrected association affects future cases.

Account context and supporting evidence

A summary should help someone understand the situation and check the conclusion. If the product says payment is delayed because of a dispute, ask it to show the communication, affected invoices and current status.

Include a case with missing or conflicting records. A useful response identifies what is known, what remains uncertain and what information is needed next. Require evidence that supports the conclusion; a source link alone is insufficient.

Decisions and permitted actions

Ask the vendor to separate recommendations from execution. Preparing a reminder, sending it and changing a ledger balance involve different authority and consequences.

For each action, identify the required checks, approval limits and escalation path. Test whether the product rechecks the account before executing a queued action, so a newly recorded payment or dispute can change what happens.

Learning from corrections

When a vendor says the product learns, ask what changes. A correction might update a payer relationship, adjust a matching rule or become an example used in a later model update. Each has different implications for review and reliability.

Ask who approves changes, how improvements are evaluated and whether an incorrect change can be reversed. NIST’s Generative AI Profile is a useful reference for evaluating generative AI risks. It does not establish that a particular product is accurate or suitable for your workflow.

4. Check integration depth and failure handling

An integration determines which parts of a workflow the product can complete and which your team must bridge. A system logo on a website is insufficient evidence of supported operations.

Ask for the connector’s current scope for your system, edition and configuration. Then trace a record through the connection rather than reviewing a list of supported applications.

ConnectionWhat to establish
Accounting or billing systemSupported records, fields, entities and write-back operations.
AR inboxMailbox scope, attachment handling, conversation linking and send permissions.
Bank accountsFeed or file coverage, available references, freshness and missing-data handling.
Payment processorsPayment status, settlement, fees, refunds and returned-payment records.
Customers’ AP portalsSubmission and acceptance visibility, manual steps and maintenance responsibility.
CRMOwnership and commercial context available to finance, with field-level responsibility.
File importsFormats, validation, duplicate detection, frequency and the person operating the import.

Read access and write-back need separate evaluation. A platform may display a proposed allocation while still requiring someone to enter it in the ledger. Another may post the allocation automatically. Have the vendor show where the work ends, which record changes and how the team confirms completion.

Agree on a source of truth for each important field. If a due date changes in the accounting system while someone edits it in the AR platform, the integration needs a defined conflict policy. The team should know which value wins and how the change is recorded.

Finally, test interruptions. Ask what happens when a connection fails after an action has been submitted but before confirmation returns. The product should be able to establish whether the action completed before retrying it, avoiding duplicate messages or entries. Include a closed accounting period and a changed invoice in the test, and check how failed work is surfaced, assigned and recovered.

5. Evaluate the workflows your team needs

Use your ranked problems to decide which workflows deserve the most attention. A platform does not need to replace every part of AR to be valuable, but its boundaries need to be clear.

Collections and follow-up

Effective follow-up depends on the current account situation. An invoice may be overdue while a customer is waiting for a corrected document, a payment is being matched or a promise to pay remains valid.

Test accounts in different states and ask what would be sent, when and why. Check how a new reply or payment changes scheduled outreach, who handles a missed promise and how someone can pause or override the process. Assess whether the product reduces investigation and inappropriate contact as well as the time spent drafting messages.

Invoice questions and disputes

Recognizing a dispute is only the beginning. Someone still needs to gather evidence, reach the right colleague, obtain a decision and communicate the outcome.

Follow a case from the customer’s message through assignment, investigation and resolution. Ask what information reaches the owner, how delays are escalated and how the final decision updates collections and accounting records. A useful workflow should make responsibility and next steps visible throughout the case.

Payment acceptance

Evaluate the payment methods your customers need and the work surrounding them. A payment link is helpful only if the payer can use it, understand what is being paid and receive an accurate status afterward.

Trace a payment from initiation through settlement and ledger recording. Ask about authorization versus settled funds, fees, partial payments, refunds and returns. Confirm which issues the AR provider resolves and which require your team or another payment provider.

Cash application

The objective is to allocate receipts correctly while reducing the work needed to establish what they settle. Include combined payments, short payments, incomplete references and parent-company receipts in the evaluation.

Check customer, invoice, legal entity, currency and allocated amount. A system should surface ambiguous cases rather than force a match. Measure accuracy among automatically applied allocations together with the share of all receipts handled and the time spent reviewing the remainder.

Reconciliation

Cash application and reconciliation are related tasks with different questions. Allocating a receipt to invoices does not complete the work of accounting for processor fees, settlement timing, returned payments and differences between bank and ledger records.

Ask the vendor to demonstrate those differences and show the resulting entries or unresolved items. During the pilot, inspect a period-end reconciliation and establish which balances the product reconciles, which remain outside its scope and who investigates discrepancies.

Reporting and forecasting

A forecast should make its assumptions visible. Payment history, current promises, disputes and known billing issues may affect expected receipts, but a forecast also needs a clear treatment of uncertain or missing information.

Compare dated forecasts with actual cash receipts over an agreed horizon. Check performance by relevant account groups as well as in total, since errors can offset each other. Ask whether the product shows why a forecast changed and which cases need investigation.

Credit and payment terms

Recommendations about credit limits or payment terms can affect both risk and customer relationships. Evaluate the evidence used, the applicable policies and the person authorized to make the decision.

Review historical cases to understand the recommendation process, then assess new recommendations under supervision. Agreement with a past decision helps explain behavior, but does not by itself demonstrate that the decision improves outcomes.

6. Examine controls, security and data use

Evaluate controls against the actions the product will take. A read-only reporting tool and a system authorized to send customer messages or post financial entries require different permissions and recovery plans.

Ask the vendor to demonstrate access by role, legal entity and action type. Where preparation and approval must be separated, verify that the system enforces the separation. OWASP’s Excessive Agency guidance recommends limiting functionality, permissions and autonomy and enforcing authorization outside the model.

The audit trail should let another person reconstruct an action from its source evidence, applicable rules, approval and execution result. A generated explanation is only one part of that record. Ask what is retained, who can access it and whether the history can be exported.

Data review should cover the AR provider and its model providers or other subprocessors. Establish what information leaves your systems, how long it is retained, whether it is used for training and how deletion works. Review independent assurance reports for their scope, period and exceptions rather than treating a security badge as an answer to every question.

Also test the operating controls: can the team stop automation, revoke access and recover from an incorrect action? Ask how model or workflow changes are tested and communicated. Our guide to building AI agents for finance teams examines these responsibilities in more detail.

7. Compare implementation effort and total cost

A realistic implementation estimate includes work on both sides. Connecting systems may be straightforward while identifying payer relationships, cleaning contacts or agreeing on approval rules takes longer.

Request a plan that names each task, its owner, dependencies and the evidence required for completion. Include data mapping, historical balances, permission setup, testing, training and a phased rollout. Clarify whether the vendor’s timeline includes your security review and internal availability.

Ask what happens after launch. Your team may still need to maintain contacts, review exceptions, investigate synchronization errors or approve configuration changes. Identify who provides support during close, how incidents are escalated and which services cost extra.

Compare costs over the same period

Request pricing at your current volume and a plausible growth scenario. Include subscription, usage, payment processing, connector or module fees, implementation, support and internal operating effort. Confirm contract minimums, renewal terms and data-export or exit charges.

An average monthly estimate can be useful if you add recurring fees, expected internal effort and one-time costs spread over the evaluation horizon. Keep the upfront cash requirement visible separately. Compare payment costs with what you already pay so the analysis captures the incremental change.

Separate cash flow, savings and capacity

Earlier collection can release working capital. If it also reduces borrowing, there may be an interest saving. Hours freed give the team capacity; they become a cash saving when spending is avoided or reduced. Count each benefit separately and avoid adding the same improvement twice.

For illustration, reducing average borrowing by $500,000 for a full year at 8% interest produces $40,000 in gross interest savings before software and implementation costs. This is arithmetic, not a benchmark or a forecast of product results.

Value the work that is actually removed. If a new platform saves reminder preparation time but creates an equivalent review queue, its net time benefit may be limited. Include setup, supervision and rework in the comparison.

8. Run a fair evaluation

A fair process uses the same requirements, evidence and scoring approach for every vendor. It also separates what a demonstration can establish from what requires observation in a pilot.

Set essential requirements before scoring

Agree on the supported accounting operations, approval controls, data conditions and acceptable error levels that a solution must meet. Include finance, the process owner and the people responsible for systems and security.

Document gaps as they appear. If a missing requirement is essential, resolve it before treating the product as eligible. Any agreed workaround needs its own owner, cost and operational assessment.

Use a consistent demonstration script

Choose a manageable shortlist and give each vendor the same case materials. These should include invoice and payment records, relevant remittances and communications, and the context needed to understand the problem. Remove or replace sensitive details while preserving relationships and amounts needed for the test.

Include difficult cases to expose limitations. For example, ask the vendor to handle a customer saying that its parent company paid an overdue invoice. Follow the reply, payment search, proposed allocation, scheduled reminder and unresolved questions. Record the evidence shown, access required and human work at each step.

Ask which parts ran in the product and which required vendor preparation or intervention. A demonstration of capability is useful evidence, but a small set of selected cases cannot establish an overall accuracy rate.

Pilot on representative work

Agree on scope, duration, baseline and success criteria before starting. Include ordinary cases as well as exceptions, and previously unseen cases where possible. Begin with supervised or non-executing recommendations before granting the authority the pilot requires.

Measure performance with explicit denominators:

  • Accuracy: correct automatic allocations or actions divided by those reviewed, with a defined review method.
  • Coverage: the share of all in-scope receipts or cases completed at the agreed level of automation.
  • Effort: total review, investigation, maintenance and correction time.
  • Control performance: incorrect actions, reversals, missed escalations and recovery time.

Show the number of cases behind each rate and identify excluded work. For payment matching, assess coverage by transaction count and value so large receipts are not obscured by many small ones.

For cash outcomes, compare similar account groups or periods and document changes in sales, terms and customer mix. Choose an observation window long enough to see the relevant payment and exception cycles. A payment received after a reminder does not, by itself, establish that the reminder caused it.

Check references and implementation experience

Speak with customers who have a similar system configuration, payment mix and exception burden. Ask what took more effort than expected, which work remained manual and how the provider handled an incident. Where possible, include a customer who reduced its use or left.

Score eligible vendors using the same evidence

Set weights before the evaluation, then score consistently. The following weights are illustrative and should reflect your own priorities.

CriterionExample weight
Resolves the priority blockers25%
Integration depth20%
Accuracy, coverage and remaining effort20%
Controls and audit evidence15%
Implementation and ongoing upkeep10%
Total cost10%

One practical scoring scale is 1 to 5, with 1 meaning substantial gaps, 3 meaning the requirement is met with understood manual work, and 5 meaning strong demonstrated fit with limited remaining work. Mark unverified claims as unverified. For each criterion, multiply the score by its weight and add the results; weights expressed as decimals produce an overall score out of 5.

Use the score to support a decision grounded in evidence. Record unresolved dependencies and do not let the weighted total override an essential requirement that failed.

9. Use these 24 vendor questions

Use this checklist to capture answers and the evidence behind them. Record whether each answer came from a live demonstration, documentation, a customer reference or a commitment to future functionality.

Integrations

  1. Which editions and configurations of our accounting system do you support today, and which records can you read and write?
  2. Which actions write back to our ledger, what checks apply and can each action be disabled?
  3. How often does data synchronize, and how are conflicting or stale records handled?
  4. How do you access our inbox, bank, payment and AP-portal information, and which steps remain manual?
  5. How do you handle multiple entities, currencies, payer identities and parent-child customer relationships?
  6. What happens during an outage, retry or closed accounting period, and how do we detect and recover from failed work?

AI behavior

  1. Which information does the AI use, and which decisions does it recommend or execute?
  2. Can we inspect the source evidence behind an explanation or suggested action?
  3. What happens when information is missing, contradictory or insufficient for a reliable decision?
  4. How do you validate payment allocations, measure accuracy and decide which cases require review?
  5. What changes when we correct the product, and how are those changes tested and approved?
  6. Can we run our own cases and see where vendor staff or manual preparation contribute to the result?

Controls and data

  1. How are permissions, approval limits, separation of duties and emergency stops enforced?
  2. Can we reconstruct an action from its evidence, rules, approvals and execution result?
  3. Which providers receive our data, how is it retained or used for training, and what deletion options apply?
  4. How are customer data and permissions kept separate, including across our legal entities?
  5. Which independent assurance reports can we review, and what systems, periods and exceptions do they cover?
  6. How do we export records, attachments and action history, and what happens when the contract ends?

Implementation

  1. What work does implementation require from each team, and what dependencies affect the schedule?
  2. Who maintains configurations, connections and exceptions after launch, and how is support provided?
  3. Can we run a supervised pilot on representative work with agreed success and stop criteria?

Pricing and proof

  1. What are the full charges at our current volume and expected growth, including implementation and exit costs?
  2. How will we measure accuracy, coverage, total effort and business outcomes against a baseline?
  3. Can we speak with customers whose systems, payment mix and operating complexity resemble ours?

10. Where Pellucid fits

Pellucid is an AI-Native accounts receivable platform for B2B finance teams.

We’re building Pellucid to work alongside existing accounting systems and connect the records and conversations behind receivables. Our direction is to help teams understand what is delaying payment, identify the next action and its owner, and enable agents to carry out permitted work within agreed controls.

People remain involved where judgment, approvals and customer relationships matter. The goal is to help businesses get paid sooner, collect more of the cash they are owed and give finance teams time back.

Evaluating how to improve your AR operations? Talk to Pellucid about your workflows and priorities.

Sources and further reading

The evaluation process, examples and suggested scorecard in this guide are Pellucid’s recommendations. They are not industry benchmarks or evidence of results achieved by a particular product.